
The Port of Rotterdam is the largest bunker port in Europe, but for many years its reputation has not been determined solely by its size. Disputes concerning bunker quantities, disagreements regarding fuel quality and reports of irregularities have prompted regulators and port authorities to intervene increasingly in a market that has traditionally been governed largely by commercial agreements between suppliers and buyers.
This development has become visible through various measures in recent years. On the one hand, as of 1 January 2026, the Port of Rotterdam has introduced a mandatory Mass Flow Meter (MFM) system for a substantial part of bunker operations by incorporating this requirement into the bunker permit regime. On the other hand, the Dutch Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate (ILT) has adopted an increasingly strict approach to the sampling requirements contained in MARPOL Annex VI.
Although these developments may at first sight appear unrelated, they share a common denominator: the determination of bunker quantities and fuel quality is being left progressively less to the market itself. Whereas parties traditionally relied on contractual arrangements, surveyors and their own operational procedures, a framework is emerging in which public law requirements increasingly dictate how bunker operations must be carried out.
1. The Mandatory Mass Flow Meter
As of 1 January 2026, bunker barges supplying residual fuels, distillates and biodiesel to seagoing vessels in the Port of Rotterdam must use an MFM system. The permit does not merely require some form of mass measurement, but specifically a Coriolis Mass Flow Meter that complies with ISO 22192:2021, the Measuring Instruments Directive (MID) and OIML R117:2019. Additional requirements apply with respect to certification, data logging, annual verification and onboard documentation. Small bunker barges with a deadweight capacity of up to 300 tonnes are exempt from this obligation. The MFM is therefore no longer an evidentiary instrument that parties may voluntarily use, but a prerequisite for carrying out certain bunker operations at all.
The legal basis for this requirement exists on several levels. At the European level, bunkering qualifies as a port service under Regulation (EU) 2017/352. Article 4 of that Regulation permits competent authorities to impose minimum requirements relating, among other things, to equipment, safety, environmental protection and reliability.
At the local level, Article 8 of the Rotterdam Port By-laws 2020 (Havenverordening Rotterdam 2020) provides the legal foundation. Article 8.1 establishes a permit requirement, Article 8.2 allows for the imposition of minimum requirements, and Article 8.3 makes it possible to attach operational and technical conditions to a permit. The MFM obligation has subsequently been elaborated in the bunker permit and the accompanying explanatory memorandum.
Where the MFM requirements are not met, the non-compliance must be reported immediately to the Harbour Master. New bunker operations may not be commenced. If a bunker operation has already started, it must in principle be suspended. Resumption is only possible under specific conditions and through the use of an alternative measurement method to which the receiving vessel has provided written consent. Furthermore, non-compliance may result in enforcement measures, revocation of permits and the application of the penalty provisions contained in Article 14 of the Port By-laws 2020.
2. The Stricter Approach to Bunker Samples
A second development concerns the enforcement of bunker fuel sampling requirements in the Netherlands. MARPOL Annex VI, Regulation 18.8.1, provides that the Bunker Delivery Note (BDN) must be accompanied by a representative sample of the fuel oil delivered, taking into account the guidelines developed by the International Maritime Organization (IMO). This sample is referred to as the MARPOL-delivered sample pursuant to Regulation 2.1.22 of MARPOL Annex VI.
Accordingly, the international regulatory framework imposes requirements not only on the fuel itself, but also on the manner in which it can be established what fuel has actually been supplied to the receiving seagoing vessel.
For many years, industry practice allowed for different methods of complying with this requirement. Samples were frequently taken from sampling points onboard the bunker barge. Under the general terms and conditions of many bunker suppliers, this sample is also regarded as the governing sample for the purpose of quality claims. However, ILT has adopted the position that stricter enforcement is required of the principle that the representative MARPOL sample must be taken at the manifold of the receiving seagoing vessel.
It should be noted that MARPOL itself does not explicitly prescribe the receiving vessel’s bunker manifold as the mandatory sampling location.
That sampling location follows from the IMO guidelines, including MSC-MEPC.2/Circ.18. Those guidelines do not in themselves have direct binding force.
However, Article 3.3(1)(b) of the Dutch Decree on Fuels and Air Pollution (Besluit brandstoffen luchtverontreiniging) requires the bunker supplier to provide a representative sample that has been taken in accordance with the IMO guidelines.
Through this legislative reference, the Netherlands has effectively incorporated compliance with the applicable IMO guidelines into national law.
The Decree on Fuels and Air Pollution has been in force since 28 April 2011. The reference to IMO guidelines is therefore not a new development, although the precise historical wording and the legal consequences of subsequent amendments must be assessed separately.
ILT considers it necessary to apply the international rules concerning bunker samples more strictly in the Netherlands than has previously been the case. Although ILT and the Port of Rotterdam pursue the same ultimate objective, it is noteworthy that the explanatory memorandum to the new Rotterdam bunker permit states that samples other than the legally required MARPOL samples may also be taken onboard the bunker barge, provided this is recorded on the BDN. The Port of Rotterdam expresses a preference for taking such samples onboard the receiving seagoing vessel, but it does not make this mandatory with respect to those additional samples.
The relevant distinction from the MFM requirement is that, in this context, the issue appears not so much to be new legislation as a stricter interpretation and enforcement of existing rules. For bunker suppliers, however, the practical consequences may be much the same. If ILT takes the view that sampling has not been carried out in accordance with the applicable regulations, this may affect a party’s evidentiary position in quality disputes and may give rise to administrative or criminal enforcement action.
Whereas the MFM requirement introduces a new public law obligation, the sampling debate demonstrates that a regulator’s revised enforcement strategy can also have a significant impact on commercial practice.
From Freedom of Contract to Regulated Bunker Operations?
Traditionally, the bunker industry has been characterised by a significant degree of freedom of contract. Suppliers, buyers and surveyors were largely free to agree between themselves on measurement methods, evidentiary standards and operational procedures. Formally, that freedom still exists, but in practice it is becoming increasingly constrained and the consequences can be significant: what may be permissible contractually can nevertheless remain unlawful under public law.
The MFM requirement directly restricts the ability of parties to choose their own measurement method. For the relevant bunker deliveries, one specific technology is prescribed as a matter of public law.
The developments concerning sampling may go even further. If ILT regards only one sampling method as compliant, the scope for contractual deviation becomes, in practical terms, very limited. Parties remain free to agree many matters under private law, but such agreements provide no protection against public law enforcement measures.
As a result, bunker practice appears to be shifting from a system in which commercial arrangements occupied centre stage to one in which public law requirements increasingly determine how bunker operations are to be conducted.
Whether parties are adequately protected by deviating contractual provisions remains open to question, particularly where such deviations have not been clearly documented.
In any event, it provides ample room for discussion.
Cherry Almeida and Claire Olbertz
Caland Advocaten
